A Horror Critic’s Checklist

Use this checklist from How to Watch a Horror Movie by Davey to put together a thoughtful, fair critique of any horror film. Type in the movie you’re watching and check off each step on your phone or computer as you go, or download the printable version below. Click through the list as you give your critique. When the slime bar is full, you’re in a good spot!

Film title

0 of 12 complete

I have separated my personal taste from my critical assessment of the film. I have identified the film’s subgenre and the goals of that tradition. I have judged the film by how well it achieves what it set out to do. I have considered the story and structure, including pacing and whether the film’s rules remain consistent. I have evaluated the craft, including cinematography, editing, sound design, effects, and performance. I have considered the film’s themes and what it is about beneath its surface. I have placed the film in context, including its influences and the moment in which it was made. I have supported my points with specific scenes, shots, or sounds. I have avoided revealing major plot points for readers who have not yet seen the film. I have noted both the film’s strengths and the areas where it could have gone further. I have identified the audience most likely to appreciate the film. I have remained open to the possibility that my view of the film may change over time.

Download the Printable Checklist (PDF)